A few days ago I posted some thoughts on The Cove Movie in my Facebook profile and shared it with some friends to spread the word.
One of them, an American living in Japan, didn’t like the documentary. I would have thought he’d want to share it with his Japanese contacts in order to raise awareness, but that wasn’t the case. He was actually upset. I think we had a good conversation that I’d like others to read as well, but I won’t share his identity.
Here’s what he said after I sent him the link to the movie’s page:
Problem is Japan isn’t the only country whaling and killing dolphins. Other countries in northern Europe do it too. Japan is just an easier target for waste-of-time/money groups like Sea Shepherd and Green Peace. If you’re going to pick on Japan, pick on the other countries doing the same thing too I say.
I didn’t agree with that, really, and so I told him:
Oh, man, you know how I love Japan. I’m not picking on it. I am aware of how nice Japanese people are! It’s not “Japan”, it’s just a little group of people in a town there, and that’s what that movie focuses on.
I know there is more going on elsewhere, and it is my hope to do something about them all, I want this planet to be much better for every living thing, but one takes these things on one at a time. This time I found this movie and wanted to pass it on.
I can’t go there to do something physical, but I have communication. Knowledge is very powerful, but the Japanese are not aware of what goes on in that place, because they’re not told. I know how good people the Japanese are and that they’d disapprove it if they were aware, and all my intention when I tagged you with this, was to tell you so that you could tell others there.
I know that if someone showed me something wrong going on in my country, hidden from people so it’s not protested against, I would, at the very least, tell people around me to create awareness of the issue. This would open the door to eventually stop that activity.
To which he had a few more things to say:
Another reason the Cove pissed me off was their practices in making it. Lying to the people of Taiji and other officials who appeared in the film telling they were not there to portray the town in a negative light.
Also, bringing that chick from Heroes (the cheerleader one) to tag along with the camera crew when she had no business doing it. What, cause she’s a surfer and loves dolphins? Using her fame from Heroes (a show I choose to no longer support) to spread the word about a town in Japan that everyone watching this movie can never really know anything about because they are not a part of the community and they’re only seeing one side that the filmmakers chose to show.
What, was she there to save the “cute little dolphins” (as she was quoted for putting it). Why doesn’t she go save the cute little kangaroos and koalas getting killed while she’s at it? At the end of the day, I felt like she wouldn’t have gotten on the camera crew if it were shooting in some little town in Iceland, but that the Japanese are seen as weak and feeble so they are easier targets and she thought they could save the dolphins.
I’m not saying the oikomi technique of killing dolphins that the people in the village in Wakayama prefecture have been doing since the 1600s isn’t cruel to animals, but then what about the genocide of kangaroos and koalas down in Australia? Or more comparatively, what about traditional spear fishing by the Native American Indians in North America? Or better yet, “There are some countries that eat cows, and there are other countries that eat whales or dolphins,” said Yutaka Aoki, fisheries division director at the Foreign Ministry. “A film about slaughtering cows or pigs might also be unwelcome to workers in that industry.” I agree with Ms. Aoki.
I think the people in Taiji were used as an example to push an agenda that however noble it may be, the techniques the filmmakers used were sneaky and unethical, not to mention bringing the cheerleader chick from heroes on board to get more teens interested was a cheap shot. You don’t see any cute cheerleaders going out to save some cows, when the systemized slaughter of cattle across the world is happening every second. And back to the koala/kangaroo killing. Mass killing for population control? Isn’t killing animals just killing animals at the end of the day?
I don’t agree with places like Sea World either. In fact I went to a sea park last summer and did my best to smile my way through it cause [my girlfriend] was having fun but meanwhile I was thinking to myself how miserable the animals must have been. Knowledge is power, and internet communication is a great tool for spreading the word, but the thing about Japan is they are not eating dolphin or whale everyday. [My girlfriend] has never eaten whale in her life. And the Japanese know about Taiji village. They just choose to let it practice its tradition without interfering.
I’m sorry if my reply is coming off as angry at you personally. I’m not angry at you, my friend. I’m angry at the makers of this film using the people in Taiji instead of going after other places in the world that are also killing dolphins. If you’re going to go after one country doing it, go after them all and change the movie name to “Coves”.
And I had my own thoughts to say about those comments:
Thank you for your reply, my friend. I can understand your position and appreciate you sharing it. I know it’s not personal against me, so don’t worry about that. I, personally, have a different opinion regarding some of the points you bring up and will share them with you below, hoping you’ll understand I’m not attacking you either.
I have no idea who the cheerleader of Heroes is,I don’t watch TV. Was it one of the surfers? Yeah, it wasn’t needed to bring such a person, but celebrities are usually used for causes they support, that’s not really new to this documentary and I don’t particularly object to that practice as long as the celebrity actually supports the cause.
Regarding the cow rebuttal that some use, I disagree with that to an extent, because cows people eat are not in the wild, they are raised. And not more cows than the ones raised are eaten. On the other hand, hunted wild animals, especially when done in large numbers, tend to face extinction, because they aren’t reproducing fast enough to compensate the hunting. So they’re not equal things to be used as an argument like that. And, if it is true that dolphin meat is sold disguised under other labels (other fish), then that could mean that they are hunting way more than people actually buys. So, what’s the point killing so many?
Another reason I disagree with that practice is that dolphin meat has toxic levels of mercury because of industrial contamination in the past decades. So the only valid reason to hunt them, which would be to eat them, is not good even in low quantities. Especially not telling people the real problem with that. Even a couple of Taiji officials were against having children fed that meat in school lunches because they know the problems.
But one important problem, which is probably the one that brought the film maker to that place in particular, is the cruelty of the method they use. Here’s an article I found regarding this, which I like the way it was put http://www.treehugger.com/files/2009/09/more-news-from-taiji-70-dolphins-released-and-quote-drops.php
Regarding the point where you say why aren’t other places mentioned, or other bad practices, one can’t expect a documentary to cover every single thing that’s wrong with this planet, can one? Focusing just on dolphin hunting, you know as a film-maker the budget issue, and can’t expect the guy to have enough to travel all over the world with team and equipment and then try to fit everything in a single movie. For whatever reason he chose Taiji, I doubt it was to pick on Japan. That doesn’t mean dolphins aren’t hunted elsewhere, but I don’t think he said that either. He’s trying to raise awareness of the problems with dolphin meat and captivity, which will help reduce the practice all over the world.
I don’t agree that because it happens elsewhere as well, then it shouldn’t be told. Is it wrong that China Blue showed the working conditions there and not in every other country were workers are being abused? Was it wrong that Bowling for Columbine showed the problem there, while violence with guns happens in other places of the world as well? Is it wrong that Erin Brockovich focused on Hinkley, California, when the contamination problems are rampant around the world? I think that raising awareness, even if showing a particular example, helps reduce the power that such an activity has elsewhere as well.
I’m truly sorry that this particular film found such a problem to be in Japan, which has issues as any country. Even if I love it, I can’t say there’s no such problem. Partly because I like Japan, is that I want that problem to be solved.
I understand that Taiji has that tradition, but it just may be one of those traditions that aren’t good. Toxicity levels have raised in the recent past, which changes the situation a bit compared to the times when the tradition started. Also, I’m sure that it originally started to supply the locals, not the country or internationally, so I doubt the numbers were high before or that it was done every day for half a year. Just because it’s been tradition doesn’t mean it shouldn’t be reviewed.
I can understand that you feel the methods to film the movie were hidden. Well, they had to be, they tried to film openly and were not permitted. If there’s nothing wrong with their practice, what is there to hide about it? Why hide? Well, the film shows why, even if they had to hide the cameras to do achieve it. It’s not like they hurt anyone or misrepresented the facts or touched up the images to make them worse. They show what they shot, don’t they?
You mention whaling as well, which I also disagree with, but the film is not about that, mostly dolphins as far as I could tell. And I’m aware that you living there, having friends from outside Japan, this is not the first time someone mentioned this to you and that you’re probably pretty tired of having this mentioned already. I’m really sorry, I didn’t mean to bother you, really.
And I really didn’t, but I understand him. Actually, I wondered about the effectiveness of the movie to stop this activity and I just found a review that puts it in words quite well. I agreed very much with the opinion of this video blogger (an Australian living in Japan too) and wanted to share it here to finish this post.
What’s your opinion? Please share this post and leave a comment.